Grandma Raised Her Granddaughter Until The Girls Father Took Her To Court

Two days before the hearing, Hazel came into my bedroom carrying Emily’s photograph.

It’s the one that sits on her dresser. Emily at twenty-five, very pregnant, laughing on the beach, with the wind blowing her hair across her face.

“Grandma,” Hazel said. “Was Mom scared when I was born?”

“A little,” I said. “Most new mothers are.”

“Did she love me?”

“More than anything in the whole world.”

Hazel sat down on my bed and studied the picture.

“Would she have wanted me to stay with you?” she asked.

I thought carefully about how to answer.

“Your mother trusted me,” I said. “She asked me to be your godmother before you were even born. But mostly, she’d want you safe. And happy.”

Hazel nodded.

Then she asked something that broke my heart.

“Do you think Dad loves me?”

I struggled.

I wanted to say no. I wanted to say yes. I didn’t know which one was true.

“I don’t know what he feels, sweetheart,” I said finally.

She looked down at the photo of her mother.

“I wish he’d just tell the truth,” she said quietly.

I hugged her.

“So do I,” I said.

That night, I heard her moving around in her bedroom. Late. Past ten o’clock.

I got up and went down the hall. Her door was cracked open. Her lamp was on.

She was kneeling on the floor beside her bed, putting things into her backpack.

“Hazel? It’s late. What are you doing?”

She jumped a little.

“Homework,” she said.

“Homework?”

“Something for tomorrow.”

I assumed she meant school. Some project she’d forgotten about until the last minute. She did that sometimes.

“Well, finish up,” I said. “Lights out in ten minutes.”

“Okay, Grandma.”

I didn’t ask what it was.

I wish I had. Or maybe I’m glad I didn’t. I still don’t know which.

The morning of the hearing, Hazel came downstairs wearing her favorite green sweater.

It was a little too small for her now. The sleeves came above her wrists. Doris had knitted it for her two Christmases ago.

“Are you sure you want to wear that?” I asked. “It’s getting tight.”

“I’m sure,” she said. “It’s green.”

I wore my old blue dress.

I couldn’t afford a cab. Brandon’s lawyers had probably spent more on one morning than I spent on groceries in a year. But we took the number 14 bus downtown, the same way we went to the library on Saturdays.

Hazel held my hand the whole way. Her backpack was on her lap. She kept one arm wrapped around it.

The courthouse was a big stone building with tall columns and a lot of steps. My knee hurt on every one of them.

Brandon was waiting outside the courtroom. He was standing next to his attorney. A tall man with silver hair and a briefcase that probably cost more than my furnace.

Caroline was standing a little apart from them. By the window. She was holding a coffee cup with both hands.

She smiled when she saw Hazel.

“Good morning, sweetheart,” she said.

Hazel nodded politely.

Brandon looked at me. Then he looked at my blue dress. Up and down.

“Ready to get this over with?” he said.

I didn’t answer him.

Inside, the courtroom seemed enormous. Dark wood everywhere. High ceilings. A big seal of the state on the wall behind the judge’s bench.

I’d never been inside a real courtroom before. Only on television.

The judge was a woman. Maybe sixty. She had short gray hair and reading glasses and a calm face that didn’t give anything away. The nameplate in front of her said Hon. Patricia Delgado.

Brandon’s attorney went first.

He talked for a long time. He talked about Brandon’s financial stability. His good job. His income, which he said out loud, and which was more money than I’d earned in the last ten years combined.

He talked about Brandon’s beautiful home. His marriage to Caroline. His church. The excellent private school just three miles from the house. Opportunities Hazel would have there that she couldn’t have with me.

Then he showed photographs.

He put them up on a big screen at the front of the courtroom.

The swimming pool. The tennis court. The big green bedroom with the white desk. The kitchen, with marble countertops and two ovens and not a single crumb anywhere.

I looked down at my hands in my lap.

Our house has peeling paint. Our furniture is old. Our kitchen has one oven, and it runs hot on the left side, and there’s a burn mark on the counter from when I set a pot down too fast in 2009.

I suddenly felt so ashamed. Sitting there in my old blue dress, with my accordion folder that wouldn’t close.

Then I looked over at Hazel.

She wasn’t looking at the screen.

She was looking at me.

Brandon’s attorney said Hazel deserved to live with her biological father.

He admitted that Brandon had been absent. He called it “a difficult period.” He said Brandon had been young and grieving and overwhelmed. He said Brandon had matured. He said Brandon deeply regretted the lost time and wanted nothing more than to make up for it.

Then the judge asked Brandon some questions herself.

“Mr. Keller,” she said. “How often have you visited Hazel during the past eleven years?”

Brandon shifted in his chair.

“Not as often as I should have, Your Honor.”

“How many times?”

He hesitated.

The courtroom was very quiet.

“None,” he said.

The judge wrote something down.

“And since you returned in March,” she said, “what steps have you taken to build a relationship with her?”

“I’ve contacted her. I’ve called.”

“Have you spent any time together? Outings? Meals? Anything?”

Brandon cleared his throat.

“She’s been reluctant, Your Honor.”

I wanted to stand up and say something. My hands were shaking in my lap.

But I waited. Priya at the law library had told me: wait your turn. Don’t interrupt. Judges don’t like it.

So I waited.

Finally, the judge turned to me.

“Mrs. Hollis,” she said. “You’re representing yourself today?”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“All right. You may speak.”

I stood up slowly. My knee cracked. Somebody behind me coughed.

I had written a whole speech in my notebook. Three pages. I’d practiced it in front of the bathroom mirror every night for a week.

I looked down at my notebook.

I couldn’t read a single word. My eyes were too blurry.

So I just talked.

“Your Honor,” I said. My voice was trembling. “I’ve been there for every birthday. Every single one. Eleven chocolate cakes. I’ve been there every time she was sick. Every ear infection. The chicken pox. The time she broke her wrist falling off the monkey bars. Every time she scraped her knees.”

I looked over at Hazel.

“She is my whole world,” I said. “Please. Please don’t take her away from me.”

Then I tried to explain the rest.

How Brandon came to my house a week after the funeral with two bottles and a pack of diapers. How he set the bag down and walked out. How he never called. Not once. How I’d filed for guardianship and he hadn’t even come to court.

How frightened Hazel was about moving. How she couldn’t sleep. How she’d started bringing Mr. Buttons to bed again.

I held up my accordion folder.

“I have all her records,” I said. “Every report card. Every doctor’s visit. Everything. Since she was a baby.”

The judge nodded. She had the bailiff take the folder.

Then I sat down.

I was sure I hadn’t said enough. I was sure I’d said it all wrong.

My whole body was shaking.

Before the judge could say anything else, Hazel slowly pulled her hand out of mine.

She stood up.

“Your Honor,” she said. “May I say something?”

My heart stopped.

The judge looked at her. Her face softened, just a little.

“Of course,” she said. “But first, you need to promise to tell the truth, young lady. Do you promise?”

“I promise,” Hazel whispered.

The judge pointed to the witness stand. It was a little wooden box beside her bench, with a chair and a microphone.

Hazel walked up to it. She was carrying her backpack. She climbed into the chair. Her feet didn’t even touch the floor. They dangled. Her green sweater sleeves were up above her wrists.

She looked so small.

Hazel took a deep breath.

“Your Honor,” she said, “a few days ago, I overheard my father talking on the phone. In our kitchen. When he came to our house.”

Brandon’s head snapped up.

“I was on the stairs,” Hazel said. “Grandma didn’t know. I wasn’t supposed to be there.”

She took another breath.

“And I know why he really wants me.”

Brandon went pale.

The judge leaned forward.

“What did you hear, Hazel?”

“He said his wife thinks Grandma kept him away from me,” Hazel said.

She looked over at Caroline. Caroline was sitting in the second row behind Brandon, holding her coffee cup. She’d gone very still.

“But that’s not true,” Hazel said. “Grandma never kept him away. He just never came.”

Then she unzipped her backpack.

She reached inside.

And pulled out an old, folded letter.

I knew it the moment I saw it.

Pale blue paper. Little white flowers printed along the top. Emily’s stationery. She’d bought a whole box of it at a gift shop on her honeymoon. Brandon must have taken a few sheets when he packed up their apartment.

He’d written that letter a month after he walked out of my house. Just once. It came in the mail with no return address.

I’d kept it all these years. In the shoebox in Emily’s cabinet. Because it was the only thing he ever wrote down about why he left.

I hadn’t known Hazel found it.

I hadn’t known she even knew where to look.

“Grandma kept this,” Hazel said. Her voice was small but clear. “It was in Mom’s cabinet. In the shoebox with her letters.”

She held it out toward the judge.

“May I show you?”

The judge nodded. The clerk came over and took the letter from Hazel and carried it up to the bench.

Brandon’s face had gone completely white. Like paper.

Caroline was staring at him.

“Brandon,” she said. Out loud. In the courtroom. “What is that?”

He didn’t answer her.

The judge unfolded the letter. She put on her reading glasses. She read it.

It was short. It didn’t take long.

When she was done, she looked up. Over her glasses. Right at Brandon.

“Mr. Keller,” she said. “Did you write this letter?”

Brandon looked down at the table in front of him.

His attorney leaned over and whispered something in his ear.

Brandon shook his head at him.

“Yes,” he said quietly. “I wrote it.”

“Do you dispute its contents?”

A long pause.

“No,” Brandon said.

Hazel’s voice shook.

“Can I tell you what it says?”

The judge looked at her for a long moment. Then she nodded.

Hazel looked straight at her father.

“He wrote that he was too young to raise me,” she said. “He wrote that he didn’t want a baby ruining his future.”

Behind Brandon, Caroline put her hand over her mouth.

Hazel kept going.

“And he wrote that Grandma shouldn’t contact him. Unless it was absolutely necessary. He wrote absolutely and he underlined it.”

The courtroom was completely silent.

I could hear the clock on the back wall ticking.

The judge looked at Brandon.

“Is that accurate, Mr. Keller?”

He nodded slowly.

“I was young,” he said. “I made a mistake.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *